We may earn commissions if you use the recommended services on this site.  

Former Starbucks CEO Schultz Found Guilty of Illegally Threatening Union Supporter, NLRB Judge Rules

Latest Business News

Former Starbucks CEO Schultz Found Guilty of Illegal Threat Against Union Supporter, NLRB Judge Rules

Violation of Labor Law by Howard Schultz

Former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz has been found guilty of violating federal labor law by a National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) judge. Administrative Law Judge Brian Gee in Los Angeles ruled that Schultz's comment to a barista in California, telling them to "go work for another company," during a "listening tour" last year, constituted an illegal threat against the worker, Madison Hall.

Concerns about Working Conditions and Union Organizing

Schultz had met with a group of Starbucks employees in Long Beach, California, to discuss concerns about working conditions. During the meeting, Hall raised the issue of collective bargaining and allegations of illegal labor practices. Schultz's response, dismissing the union-related concerns and suggesting that Hall should find employment elsewhere, led to the ruling against him.

Starbucks' Response and Unionizing Efforts

Starbucks, in its statement, did not directly address the finding that Schultz violated the law. The company emphasized that it conducted listening sessions nationwide to gather input on improving the experiences of its employees. Lawyers for Starbucks Workers United, the organization leading the unionizing efforts, have not yet responded to the ruling.

Allegations of Illegal Union-Busting

Starbucks and Schultz have faced allegations of widespread illegal union-busting from workers, labor groups, and Democratic lawmakers. The company has denied these claims and is currently defending itself against multiple complaints before the NLRB and an investigation by the U.S. Department of Labor.

Implications and Potential Appeals

The judge's decision can be appealed to the five-member NLRB and, if necessary, to a federal appeals court. In addition to ruling against Schultz, Judge Gee dismissed a separate claim that Starbucks unlawfully interrogated workers during the meeting. Starbucks expressed satisfaction with the ruling, stating that the listening session was lawful and aligned with their past practices. This case, identified as Starbucks Corp, National Labor Relations Board, No. 21-CA-294571, highlights the ongoing tensions surrounding labor practices and union organizing within the company.

Implications of Schultz's Labor Law Violation Ruling for New Business Ventures

Understanding the Schultz Labor Law Violation Case

The recent ruling against former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz by a National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) judge has significant implications for new business ventures. Schultz was found guilty of violating federal labor law when he suggested that a barista, who raised concerns about union organizing and collective bargaining, should seek employment elsewhere if dissatisfied with Starbucks. This comment was deemed an illegal threat against the worker.

Impact on Employee Relations and Unionizing Efforts

This case underscores the importance of how businesses handle employee concerns and unionizing efforts. New businesses must be aware of the legal boundaries when discussing union-related issues with employees. Dismissing concerns or suggesting that employees find other employment could be perceived as threats and result in legal consequences, as seen in Schultz's case.

Allegations of Illegal Union-Busting

The allegations of widespread illegal union-busting faced by Starbucks and Schultz serve as a cautionary tale for new businesses. It's crucial for new ventures to understand labor laws and the rights of workers to organize. Ignorance or violation of these laws can lead to damaging allegations, legal battles, and a tarnished reputation.

Appeals and Future Implications

While the ruling against Schultz can be appealed, the case has already highlighted the ongoing tensions surrounding labor practices and union organizing within companies. For new businesses, this case serves as a reminder of the importance of maintaining open, respectful dialogue with employees, particularly when it comes to sensitive issues like unionization.
Story First Published at: https://www.cnbc.com/2023/10/09/ex-starbucks-ceo-schultz-illegally-threatened-union-supporter-nlrb-judge-rules.html
Brought to you by BusinessFormation.io
Know Your State's Registered Agent Requirements: What is a Registered Agent
Learn How To Create An LLC: What Is An LLC and How To Start an LLC Online

LLC Filing & Registered Agent Services

Compare Online LLC Filing Services Today

We work with the market leaders in business formation and registered agent services.

Getting started is simple and inexpensive. Form your business today & secure your brand name before someone beats you to it! Click below to view the Top 3 Best LLC and registered agent service providers.
View Top 3 Providers Now

Filing An LLC Can Be Complicated

Streamline Your LLC Filing Online for $39

Northwest Registered Agent is the best-rated service for first time filers.

Get professional LLC formation & registered agent services for only $39 + state filing fee. This offers includes your full LLC setup, plus a private business address, lifetime support, and more.

Trusted by Millions. Save 82% Today.