TikTok Allows Users to Opt Out of Algorithm: Safeguarding Cognitive Liberty
TikTok's Algorithm Update for European Union Users
TikTok recently made a significant announcement that users within the European Union will soon have the option to disable its highly engaging content-selection algorithm. This change is driven by the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA), which aims to regulate AI and digital services in alignment with human rights and values. The algorithm, known for learning from users' interactions and shaping their preferences and behaviors, will no longer have full control over users' experiences without their awareness or consent. This opt-out feature is a crucial step towards protecting cognitive liberty, the fundamental right to self-determination over our mental experiences.
Enhancing User Experience and Prioritizing Popular Content
With the new algorithm opt-out feature, users will have more control over their TikTok feeds. Instead of being confined to algorithmically curated "For You" pages and live feeds, they will be able to see trending videos in their region and language. Additionally, a "Following and Friends" feed will present content from creators they follow in chronological order. This shift prioritizes popular content within their region, rather than content selected solely for its ability to capture attention. Furthermore, the law includes provisions that ban targeted advertisements to users between 13 and 17 years old, while offering improved information and reporting options to flag illegal or harmful content.
The Need to Protect Cognitive Liberty
In a world increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence, Big Data, and digital media, the importance of safeguarding cognitive liberty is gaining recognition. Various initiatives and proposals, such as the EU AI Act, UNESCO's human rights-centered approach to AI, and the OECD's principles for responsible governance of emerging technologies, address aspects of the problem. However, they often focus on subsets of the issue, such as privacy or data minimization, without providing a comprehensive approach to protecting our ability to think freely. Without robust global legal frameworks, developers and providers of these technologies may avoid accountability. Incremental changes are insufficient; lawmakers and companies must urgently reform the business models on which the tech ecosystem is built.
A Comprehensive Approach: Regulations, Incentives, and Redesigns
To effectively protect cognitive liberty, a well-structured plan is necessary. It should combine regulatory standards, incentives, and commercial redesigns. Regulatory standards must govern user engagement models, information sharing, and data privacy, while strong legal safeguards should be in place to prevent mental privacy intrusion and manipulation. Companies deploying algorithms must be transparent about their workings and have a duty to assess, disclose, and adopt safeguards against undue influence. Similar to corporate social responsibility guidelines, companies should be legally required to assess the impact of their technology on cognitive liberty, providing transparency on algorithms, data use, content moderation practices, and cognitive shaping.
Efforts such as impact assessments, integral to legislative proposals like the EU's Digital Services Act and the US's proposed Algorithmic Accountability Act and American Data Privacy and Protection Act, should focus on measuring AI's influence on self-determination, mental privacy, freedom of thought, and decision-making. This assessment tool would require detailed descriptions of algorithms, data sources and collection, and evidence of technology's effects on user cognition.
Tax incentives and funding can play a crucial role in fostering innovation in business practices and products that uphold cognitive liberty. Governments can offer tax breaks and funding opportunities, as proposed in the Platform Accountability and Transparency Act, to companies collaborating with educational institutions to create AI safety programs that promote self-determination and critical thinking skills. Research and innovation for tools and techniques that detect AI model deception could also benefit from tax incentives.
Embracing Design Principles for Cognitive Liberty
Technology companies should adopt design principles that prioritize cognitive liberty. Features like adjustable settings on platforms like TikTok or greater control over notifications on devices, such as Apple products, are steps in the right direction. Incorporating additional features that enable self-determination, such as labeling content as human- or machine-generated with "badges
Implications for New Businesses
The shift in TikTok's algorithm policy, driven by the EU's Digital Services Act, signals a broader trend towards prioritizing cognitive liberty in the digital landscape. For new businesses, especially those operating in the digital space, this presents both challenges and opportunities.
Challenges and Opportunities
The challenge lies in the need to redesign business models that have traditionally relied on algorithmic user engagement and data-driven personalization. This could mean rethinking marketing strategies, user experience design, and data management practices. However, it also opens up opportunities for innovation. New businesses can differentiate themselves by prioritizing cognitive liberty in their design principles, creating user experiences that respect and enhance users' self-determination and mental privacy.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the move towards safeguarding cognitive liberty is not just a legal or ethical necessity, but also a potential competitive advantage. New businesses that proactively embrace this trend, rather than resisting it, will be better positioned to succeed in the evolving digital landscape. They will not only be complying with emerging regulations but also meeting the growing demand among users for greater control over their digital experiences.
.svg)
